Looking more closely at my own post, I guess 2 and 4 are basically the same thing...I want something reasonably priced, but if I can get good performance out of a longer-wearing tire, I'd be willing to pay a little more to widen the gap 'til I'll have to buy again.Toyo Proxes T1R. They will meet your criteria, but since you only put "cost" for #2, does that mean you're looking for cheap? What is your budget?
I don't think I've ever spend more than $150 on a tire, and I think that's a reasonable cap. $100 each is more commonly what I've spent, but if the T1R's have better wear, more money is ok I'm sure.