good points, it's one of the reasons i don't do much talking about pad compounds. Not only can the same pad not work between SoCal and Minnesota, i've seen the same pad be completely different, on the SAME car, SAME canyon..DIFFERENT driver. Pads, in regard to the enthusiast, are the fine tuning of the braking system.
Even daily drivers can treat their DD pads differently, some people think daily driving is the canyon run they do 3 days a week on the way home from work. however, most people should be "safe" with input from others on here as at least a basis that won't get them into trouble. if i buy Carbotech's cause someone said that, it drops to -10 here and i go out driving, i'll still have braking, but it's going to take more effort....and then i'll buy something different. If i buy Reds and decide they still dust too much for me, i'll clean my wheels a bit more....and then buy something different. i'm not going to fly off a canyon or into a wall at a track.
As with most DIY or performance related info, it should all be taken with caution. just because this guys says it's OK on the internet doesn't mean it is. do research, get as much feedback as possible, and in the case of brakes, take it slow, feel them out, how are they working....don't use blind trust, it can be scary.
i've never looked at any of the brake stickies, so i will as i do this i'm sure. but i'm hoping there's a list of what's out there somewhere, both pads and rotors....since we get those posts all the time, it might help eleviate those.